What forge is cheap and well made for a beginner

I’m a 14 year old and i’m interested in being a blacksmith and iv had my eye on a Whitlox Mini Forge that is for $150 and i’m not sure if an old style pot like structure made of steel/cast iron for farriers is better than the Whitlox forge that uses wood. They are both the same price and both seem ok for beginners.

Thank you

Personally I went with gas. You can get propane just about anywhere around here. Coal not so much. I got no input on those forges but offer the little knowledge I have

Just in case you are still looking…find/aquire an old propane or refrigerant bottle. Carefully vent and clear the inside. Cut a 4"-6"hole in the center of the (technically) top and bottom (although you really only need 1 opening
, 2 lets you run longer stock). Use part of tour budget at home depot for a bag of ‘Owinfs Corning: ROXUL" (ROXUL can hold its own with ceramic type blankets). Go to hightemptools.com and order about 20# (thin coat) to 55# (thicker coat)of Mizzou. While waiting cut a 2" gole in the middle of the side of the bottle. Weld (or get someone to do it 4 you) a 1.5"-2" section of schedule 40 black pipe (acpid/remove threaded section first) drill and tap 3-4 1/4-20 holes in the 2" welded pipe. Return to hightemptools.com and order a single venturi burner and a 0-30 psi regulator/POL/5’-10’ propane connection. By this time thw Mizzou should arrive. PM me for mixing/curing instructions (can either give a quick ru by vn-down or mail/fax you a copy. Once the burner and reg kit arrive, get a 20# bottle from the closest place to you (for now). Put burner through 2" pipe and pin inbut I with 3-4 bolts you made holes for, but make sure it does not point straight down the middle…angle to one side or across the top a bit…should havw said that around the “weld 2” of 2" pipe…mix and dry/cure Mizzou over ROXUL" part…apologies… once curing instructions are complete…heat and beat some steel. You should easily reach weld temps, with an ITC100 coat over the Mizzou (get it later…$$$$$$) you can hit smelting temps.
All of that should be right around your budget.
I did it, welding 2 20# propane bottles together, 2 burners (until welding temp is hit, then I cut 1 off) and can weld 5160 (stacks of 1/4"x1 3/4"x6" of 5-7 pieces) in about 3-4 heats , then can draw out to what I wan (5160 can take the heat and moves u der hammer easier close to welding temps…can always thermal cycle/ normalize IF tou are worried about grain size, but I have had no issues after proper HT…it’s virtually bullet proof when I’m done everything)

Sent from my SM-N920P using Blacksmith Forums Mobile App

Thank you for the great idea for the forge ill do that for my next forge if the one i currently have wears out.

Got any shots of your current one?

i dont have any cameras but i ordered it on the internet so ill send the forge link to you.whitloxhomestead.com/products/wh … ired-forge

If you are asking me, no…but im about to head out to it to fire it up for a little bit and can get a couple (althouugh ir may take a couple days to get to it…(legal paperwork dealing with NJ, and appointments with my SSD/SSI lawyer…not enough hours [or meds!lol]in a day!). I have 2 projects going on. One a machete along the lines of bowie meets khyber Charay, for a friend made predominantly of 5160 stacked and welded. The other is a “learning curve” project following Aeiel Salaveria’s process for chainsaw damascus san mai over a 1095 core (I’ve had some medical down time and am using this to get back into the swing of things).

Visit Blacksmith Gifts for shirts, caps, and more | Buy, sell, or trade Blacksmith Tools at Blacksmith Trading Post

Created and Maintained by Little Acorn